Bend Over Dude, You’re Getting A Dell
by Chad Lakkis on July 7, 2008 at 2:46 am
Manufacturers strive to create innovative products and we as consumers work day and night to afford them. We exit our vehicles and are greeted by the open arms of big box retailers housing shelf after shelf of electronic excess.
We fork over handfuls of hard earned cash for microscopic phones and wafer thin laptops. Each item is priced, each price must be met, and it is instilled in our minds that we get what we pay for … but do we really?
As a blogger you are expected to offer up your opinion and provide your readers with a unique perspective. The more successful outlets do this in a timely and creative fashion on a daily basis. Staying on top means getting every ounce of capability out of everything you have at your disposal … including your hardware.
I bought a Dell laptop months ago with the intention of using it as a command center both at home and on the road. I wanted something powerful enough to run all the image and video editing software that I would need to keep Ripten rocking day and night. I hit the ground running, and everything seemed to be working great, until I decided to record some on-screen video.
Time and time again I tried to record audio and video feeds that displayed on my screen with no luck. I would get the video to record no problem, but the audio just wouldn’t record. I searched for alternative drivers on Dell’ site and consulted Dell’s support page to no avail.
Fully frustrated with my semi new purchase, I opened my wallet and switched my focus to software. I began to look at different types of software in the hopes that one would work. I tried Camtasia, Super Screen Recorder, WM Recorder, and a few others I can’t even remember — most trials, but a few required purchase. None remedied the situation. Thoroughly exhausted I gave up for a while, but eventually found myself needing to do it again.
As I began my prep work for this years E3, I thought I would give it one last go before scrapping my laptop (HULK SMASH) and buying a new one. At this point I was convinced that it was a hardware issue, and that the manufacturer of the video card built it with their head up their ass. In what I promised myself would be my final attempt, I searched the web for software yet again.
Being that my problem was audio, I limited my search to “record on screen audio”. The suggested software Google spit back was the ACA Screen Recorder. I installed the trial version, but was met by the same unsuccessful result. The software did however display a link that claimed to address the issue, so I clicked through and discovered that my sound card should have three audio recording options (listed below).
- Microphone/Mic - The audio will be captured from the microphone port
- Line-in/Line In - The audio will be captured from the Line-in port
- Stereo Mix/Mono Mix/WAVE Out - The audio will be captured from the sound card’s speakers port
What? Stereo Mix? Where the fuck is my stereo mix? I only see two options, Mic and Line-in. Perplexed, I refocused my efforts on Google and began to search for the missing third option.
It was not long before I encountered multiple threads started by equally frustrated and confused consumers suffering from the same misfortune. Oddly enough they were all Dell owners with the same SigmaTel brand audio card that I had.
As I dug deeper into the various threads, I soon discovered that the issue had nothing to do with the hardware itself, and everything to do with the restrictions placed on it by the PC manufacturers.
Some believe that Dell, and several other computer manufacturers such as Gateway and Pac Bell, were pressured by the RIAA (Record Industry Association of America) into disabling the stereo mix functionality. If true, I find it disturbing that at no time did any of the aforementioned manufacturers see it fit to explain the restrictions they were imposing on our hardware.
One blogger explained that he contacted Dell seeking a solution for his stereo mix woes, and they offered him one — for a $99 fee.
“Since my desktop is new, I decided to contact Dell. After a long online chat and a phone call, Dell told me they had the solution, but if I wanted to know it would cost me $99.00.”
So that we are all clear, the evidence points to Dell appeasing the RIAA by disabling hardware, only to have their customer service reps turn around and offer a solution to their consumers that reverses the alteration they made in the first place at a premium price. I am no rocket scientist, but that sure as fuck sounds fishy to me.
In the end, I was able to restore my laptop’s stereo mix functionality by following a series of registry edits outlined here. While I am now able to record on-screen audio and video, this solution is not something that I recommend everyone attempt, as those who lack the necessary experience to make registry edits could unintentionally cause more harm than good.
The unfortunate reality here is that prebuilt computers are potentially becoming nothing more than an advertising platform for big time brands and a way for highly influential organizations to impose their will on the unaware masses. In the event I decide to make use of a PC again in the future, I will build it with my own two hands.
Update: A Dell Community Ambassador has responded to this post in the comments section below stating that the outbound links in this article are specific to laptops (as was the issue I was having). He has provided a link he claims will rectify the issue, however it is unclear if this will work for all Dell computers that have had the sound card feature disabled by the company.
Also, this does not explain why it was disabled in the first place. If you have a Dell desktop computer with this issue, or the link below simply does not work for your Dell laptop, please let me know in the comment section below or email me at chad@ripten.com.
 |
|
- Toys’R'Us Scraps “Bend Over” Bundle, Replaces With 2 New Bundles - Both Suck
- Biggest Wii ‘bend-over’ of them all hits 2,500 Brits
- Sony PSP Preview: Syphon Filter: Logan’s Shadow
- Shaky-Cam Confirms Balrog and Sagat in Upcoming SFIV
- Gaming Deals of the Week
- Halo 3: Master Chief Costume Sells for $21,149.00 On Ebay
- Microsoft at Play.com Live: Aims for Wii60
- Nadia Oxford, Contributor (Canada)
on July 7, 2008 7:49 am
You could of course install drivers from another hardware manufacturer, i think i have drivers from a toshiba laptop installed on my dell inspiron which enable the missing options, although the need to do this shouldn’t exist in the first place, although i have my doubts as to whether this is due to the RIAA.
on July 7, 2008 8:31 am
The first thing I do when buying a computer from Dell/Sony/et al is format the hard drive (deleting all their goofy recovery partitions) and install a fresh copy of Windows. Given you found a registry solution, this would almost certainly have prevented your problem.
on July 7, 2008 9:16 am
Hello Chad:
My name is Chris and I’m a Community Ambassador for Dell computers.
You didn’t state in your post, but the links you forwarded to indicated you were dealing with a laptop with Windows XP.
If this is the case, our Sigmatel R171789.exe XP drivers unlock the “Stereo Mix” feature. Refer to the following link:
R171789.exe
Please let me know if you have any additional questions regarding this feature.
Regards,
Chris Byrd
Dell Digital Life Liaison
on July 7, 2008 10:06 am
Chris,
The fact that your company now has a link to rectify the issue is great, however from what I have read this link does not work for all Dell computers that have had this feature disabled.
Furthermore, simply providing a link does not explain why the feature was disabled in the first place.
Any clarification you would be willing to offer would be much appreciated.
Best,
Chad
on July 7, 2008 10:23 am
That sure has hell does sound fishy.
What’s scary is that it’s now conceivable. To explain, it’s easy for some apologists to dismiss any accusation that the RIAA is perpetuating conspiracies, but the problem is that the RIAA (and its cousin the MPAA) has gotten so big and has been acting so evil in the recent past that it’s now a reasonable null position to assume the RIAA has its hands in every till.
Sounds like it’d be a good reason to just buy a third party sound card - if only it weren’t a laptop.
Big box manufacturers are doing more and more of this stuff. I don’t trust them anymore (as if I ever did).
on July 7, 2008 10:39 am
Perfect example of large corporations looking out for what’s best for consumers……….not.
on July 7, 2008 12:19 pm
Chad, have you heard about ocz’s do it your self laptops?
The first ones are now available, it’s sorta bare bones laptop, you have to provide the cpu, memory, os.
http://www.buy.com/prod/ocz-barebone-gaming-notebook/q/loc/101/208111924.html
An interesting concept, one that I hope is successful and becomes a valued alternative to pre-built machines.
I fully support building pc’s (and laptops) yourself, you choose better quality components and generally do not have to deal with the hassle involved in buying cheap overpriced pre-built machines and all the crap that comes with them.
any way, check them out (ocz diy) and see if that may be an option for you.
on July 7, 2008 7:15 pm
I thought Stereo Mix problems were old hat and not confined to laptops. I remember building machines years ago and working through issues with soundcards that didn’t support stereo mix. This was long before the music industry came up with the brilliant idea of suing customers. That said, I think it sucks hard if the suspicions of the current trend are true, but I have no doubt that if it becomes widespread, innovative solutions will be forthcoming.
on July 7, 2008 11:25 pm
Our company was having similar issues with a brand new Dell Latitude 620 with the Sigma chipset. We needed to perform video/audio capture (using Fraps) during play sessions, while our research participants were located inside an fMRI machine at Stanford Hospital (for real-time brain mapping), and we could not find a software-based solution to the problem of no audio being recorded.
I tried loading a variety of non-Dell Sigma drivers and even attempted (unsuccessfully) some recommended registry edits, all to no avail (except for a cheesy headphone-out-to-Line-In hardware workaround).
We ended up having a local shop custom-build us a laptop, which worked flawlessly from the very get-go.
On paper, purchasing our systems from Dell would appear to be cost effective. But when we add in the hidden cost of performing this pointless “troubleshooting”, due in large part to the apparent influence of the RIAA’s and MPAA’a paranoid IP protection schemes, we’ve quickly learned to save money by either building them ourselves, or ordering from smaller, non-Dell companies.
Thanks LC for the link for ocz’s custom-built laptops. I’ll be checking that out for our next purchase.
on July 7, 2008 11:27 pm
Fundamental fault - Why would some one buy a high end computer from some company (as they are rip-offs) esp. since you mentioned that you are an advanced user?
For lees price, I think one can build a better computer than those “dell gaming” systems.
on July 7, 2008 11:39 pm
There are plenty of options for building desktops, laptops on the other hand, not so much, that’s why I linked the ocz.
on July 7, 2008 11:44 pm
fdsfdfgfd!!! i just tried recording something with my computer and it doesnt have a stereo mix option!!!! WTH!
on July 7, 2008 11:45 pm
Hmm, that $99 sounds alot like the Dell On Call service I used to work for. Basically it’s basically additional software support not covered by your hardware warranty.
They probably figured that since you could hear sound, the sound card and related hardware must be functioning fine, ergo this would be a software problem/configuration error somewhere that you would need the advance DOC plan to fix.
Yeah, I agree it seems really sneaky, thats why I left the company.
on July 7, 2008 11:46 pm
Penguin, I bet your computer doesn’t even have USB ports.
on July 7, 2008 11:51 pm
By no means I would like to sound like a fan boy, which I am not, but… why did you buy Dell in a first place, especially if you “wanted something powerful enough to run all the image and video editing software”? Why didn’t you buy a Mac? :)
I have been using Windows (since 3.11) and Linux (since Slackware 2.4, which is ancient) but switched to Mac OS X (running on MacBook Pro) completely about a year ago.
No intention to start any kind of argument which platform is better - this topic is worthless - but having substantial experience with all three, I would suggest that you would keep your options open and take a closer look at Mac. Mac OS X is very stable, fast, secure, and overall very capable system.
Check it out :)
on July 8, 2008 12:07 am
Hey Mortum,
Thanks for the comment. I am actually considering the purchase of a Mac, however to be clear, this has nothing to do with the issues I experienced above.
Chad-
on July 8, 2008 12:24 am
Oh, I totally get your rather eloquent attempt to expose this two-faced nature of corporate greed… but, every time I read something about either Dell or Windows, I feel compelled to stick my 25c :)
on July 8, 2008 12:47 am
Thanks for this.
I have a fairly new Dell XPS 1330 (came with Vista)
I removed Vista, formatted the drive and installed XP on it and then installed the standard Dell XP drivers (eg chipset, broadcom, but also including the one for the Sigmatel sound card - R158235).
Went to control panel/sounds - no Stereo Mix!
Downloaded the new audio Dell driver from the link above (driver R171789) and lo and behold I now have stereo mix
on July 8, 2008 7:34 am
Unfortunately, defective audio-in capability is not a new issue for dell laptop users. A quick google search will demonstrate a number of different Dell models with problematic sound. I purchased a Dell 700m back in ‘04, and audio-in functionality was essentially non-existent. The 700m caused quite a bit of discussion back then, and there was even a website dedicated to the issue, which itself no longer exists (recall700m.com).
No sufficient fixes were ever offered by Dell, and there was speculation as to whether the issue was a driver or a hardware defect. After months of driver tweaking, most of us agreed that it was a sound card defect, and a few users claimed to have found a hardware fix involving a soldering iron.
I pestered Dell for a few weeks, they replaced my motherboard to no avail, and they eventually sent me a creative audigy2 PCMCIA sound card for free. Other users moved on to USB headset/microphones and USB audio dongles, and still others went the bluetooth headset route.
It’s sad to see that Dell still doesn’t care. I’m on a Macbook now, and I’d rather go without than switch back.
Here are a few threads concerning the 700m audio issue:
http://www.dellcommunity.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=insp_audio&thread.id=20526&view=by_date_ascending&page=1
http://www.tinyscreenfuls.com/2005/05/dell-inspiron-700m-sound-input-design-flaw/
http://www.tinyscreenfuls.com/2005/07/lots-of-people-hit-by-the-dell-inspiron-700m-sound-input-design-flaw/
on July 8, 2008 8:49 am
Hey ChrisBatDell,
I bought a E520 desktop (and downgraded to XP pro) about a year ago and the lack of “what-u-hear” has annoyed me since. I even paid for the “SoundBlaster HD Sound” option (which I thought was a hardware thing, but turn out to be just a different driver). I tried messing with different types of drivers and almost went as far as to buy an old sound card, but I ran out of pci slots.
I have used freecorder with some success to grab from sites like myspace. But I’d still like to have the option of the wave out. What do you suggest for Desktops with the SigmaTel chips?
on July 8, 2008 7:31 pm
Just another reason to get linux. http://www.ubuntu.com/
on July 9, 2008 11:17 am
Hey Iceman. I just thought I’d point out that it is *never* a company’s goal to “look out for what’s best for consumers.” A company’s only goal is to make as much money as possible, which means providing only as much customer “service” as necessary to create the illusion that they care.
on July 9, 2008 7:59 pm
Hey skylinkdave. I guess that’s why Dell houses their sales team in the states, but has all their customer support routed to India.
Apparently sale related calls go smoother when you speak to someone you can understand, and support calls end faster if you are forced to speak to someone you can’t.
on July 10, 2008 12:16 pm
Hey Chad!
I just wanted to stop by and let you know that we *are* listening. We are currently working through a few details and will be able to share more information about this issue shortly. =)
Regards,
Chris Byrd
Dell Digital Life Liaison
on July 11, 2008 9:23 am
Chad, I found this on another site. Its a user comment that claims Dell has done this with other cards too…..
“My company bought a bunch of Dell optiplex desktops with realtek HD integrated sound a year ago and they’ve all got the stereo mix disabled. I did some searching on google for a solution and found what you need to do.
1. Download the SoundMax driver from Dell’s website and extract it somewhere. Then open up ADIHDAUD.INF located in SMAXWDM folder in the driver folder.
2. Find the line HKR,AD1984\\Disable, OutR, 1, 01 ;; Disable Stereo Mix Capture Node
3. Change the “01″ to 00 and save it
4. Run “setup” and select “uninstall” existing driver - reboot
5. Run “setup” and select “install” new driver - ignore the Windows XP auto install setting and ignore the “non certified” driver warning - reboot
6. Go to start menu > run > type: “regedit” [enter] (without quotes)
7. Click on “edit > search” and look for AD1984.
8. For each registry key/folder of AD1984, find the subfolder/key that says MicBP and OutR and change their associated binary values from 01 to 00. For some people, re-installing the driver in this fashion already produces a 00 while for others, the change must be made manually.
9. Reboot
That should allow you to use Stereo Mix like normal.”
on July 11, 2008 7:50 pm
I’d say it’s pretty foolish to expect anything but the utmost bare minimum of functionality from an OEM laptop audio interface. I’m honestly surprised to hear you ultimately did get your stereo mix feature at all.
I’m surprised you’re not also complaining, for instance, about the quality of the DACs, or about the lack of lush bass on the built-in speakers, etc… There are reasonable expectations, and then there are unreasonable ones. Try to keep things in perspective.
If you’re doing any kind of professional audio production on a laptop, you’ll want an external soundcard. Any pro or hobbyist grade outboard interface will offer you a feature to record what other applications play.
on July 11, 2008 9:10 pm
Hey jw,
Thanks for the comment. As nice as it sounds, I don’t need “lush” sound. I am running a blog, not editing audio for a feature film. The term “pro” is relative.
In terms of perspective, I do not find it unreasonable to expect a card to perform as it was intended to by the manufacturer.
The card is working now and I am happy with it. It may not be on par with that of an external card, but that was not the nature of my complaint in the first place.
Chad-
on July 22, 2008 1:03 am
Just another spin of the crazy wheel from Dell. But it’s like you said yourself, PC? Build it yourself. :-) (oh, or buy an Levno, duh…) haha
Cheers, great article.
on July 26, 2008 4:28 am
format the hard drive, install ubuntu. done. in fact Dell sells laptops with Linux preinstalled so it could be even easier…
on August 4, 2008 9:21 am
just seconding the Mac option… as far as recording anything at all, the Mac is an easier, more user friendly option all the way around. Since each Mac ships with the iLife suite, which includes Garageband, you have a built-in Podcast creation studio shipping with every new Mac.
Actually, you could even pick up a cheaper used G4 Powerbook if you wanted to, and still run the iLife ‘08 apps with very little performance difference from running them on a shiny new MacBook or MacBook Pro.
Add in the fact that you can dual or triple boot between Windows, Linux and MacOSX on a MacBook, or even run Parallels and run Mac and Windows at the same time, and the reasons to get a Mac laptop over a PC laptop become more compelling.
Like the other guy, I am not trying to argue the merits of one OS over the other, just that you have a more complete out of the box solution for this kind of content creation with a Mac.